January 11, 2011

  • Sarah Palin Charged With Accessory To Murder

    OK, admittedly a sensational headline…but I did dream it!  Let me explain.  Saturday, my “wife” Sabine flew into Los Angeles from El Salvador on a short layover before returning to Germany and eventually Africa.  We had a wonderful lobster lunch on the marina:


    Back to LAX for the long trip home…as shot from my sunroof

    And now for the reason you clicked this…the dream headline in the title.  Before I left for the airport to pick Sabine up, I posted the following on facebook:

    After 1 day, the post had nearly 60 comments, so it clearly struck a nerve with people.  The lone right wing gun advocate who commented however, was no match for my liberal friends.  After a while, I left the fray, and let the interwebs duke it out.  I devote plenty of space on this blog to my views on Sarah Palin as well as gun control.  My positions are well documented.  Regular readers may remember the eyewitness accounts that Sabine and her friends provided from the Virginia Tech shootings several years ago:

    I stand by my original statement on facebook above.  I even blogged about the lunacy of Sarah Palin’s use of gun crosshairs in my April Fool’s Day post last year.  While Sarah Palin is not directly culpable for the actions of a lone nutjob, her words do have meaning and she should be held accountable (if only to never be elected to public office).  She’s clearly backtracking, as evidenced by the removal of certain tweets and messages.  Meanwhile, bigoted teabaggers like Rush Limbaugh, are pulling out all the stops to direct attention away from themselves and their dangerous rhetoric.  Kudos to Pima County Sheriff Clarence Dupnik for having the balls to call out these cowards on their vitriol.


    Here’s the victim of this attack herself, Gabby Giffords, prophetically admonishing Sarah Palin on her evil actions and how they have consequences!


    Who’s next Sarah?

    As psychologist and neuroscientist Drew Weston said, “Saturday was not the first time Gabby Giffords — or countless other lawmakers, candidates, and elected officials, including President Obama — was confronted at a campaign rally or town hall meeting by gun-toting bullies [sic, Republicans], whose primary goal (at least until this weekend) was intimidation. That bringing a concealed weapon within that proximity to an elected official could be legal in the world’s longest-lasting democracy is both surreal and shameful — and now it threatens that democracy.

    In my opinion, Keith Olbermann summed it up best:


    Here’s a smattering of the nearly 60 comments from my facebook page.  They speak for themselves:

    In the Daily Beast today, Howard Kurtz says “Don’t Blame Sarah Palin“, but as John Cory points out:

    “Mr. Kurtz is wrong.  The killer is not “a lone nutjob.” He is one of us, clothed and fed on perpetual war and the dialog of destruction.

    We have become a nation of, by and for perpetual war. Perpetual war is our addiction and our language, and as Kurtz so chillingly admits – war is the metaphor of politics and business and daily discourse.

    But I tell you that a nation of perpetual war and constant fear eventually succumbs to self-hatred and self-loathing. It becomes consumed by the value of extremism in the maintenance of empty empire through the deceit of language. A nation of perpetual war numbs itself to violence by constant repetition of the rhetoric of death and mayhem and the slogans of militarism. A nation of perpetual war does not value human life – but rather the hollow rhetoric about human life.

    Mr. Kurtz and others would have us avert our eyes and avoid looking into the mirror and facing the reflection of our words and deeds.

    I can only imagine what Mr. Kurtz and others would have written had the shooter been named Mohammed Abdullah.

    Christina Taylor Greene was 9 years old. She was born on a day of death and madness, September 11, 2001, and she died on a day of death and madness. She is, in the flippant jargon of perpetual war – collateral damage.

    Words have power.

    Yesterday, 20 human beings were shot and 6 human beings were killed.”

Comments (25)

  • Holy moly, what feedback on that status!  Btw, that picture of Sarah Palin will haunt me tonight in my dreams, thanks.

  • You should send that picture of MS Sarah Palin to NBC and dare them to show it off. Or may be Fox News guys.

  • @Roadlesstaken - Happy early Halloween :)
    @ZSA_MD - Thanks Zakiah…I might just do that!

  • no match? bring any and all your people and lets have a proper discussion…..you failed miserably the last time. and I’m still waiting for ONE scenario from anyone where any form of gun control will work in our country….

  • @upersleder - I think the discussion on facebook was pretty proper!  You were the sole voice for guns.  Doesn’t get more mismatched than that.  Plus any first grader could tell you that if you get rid of the guns less people would die.  It’s not rocket science!  

  • I don’t use facebook much, but maybe I would more if I had friends with great conversations like this.  Look for my friend request  
    (My childhood friends and family call me Darlene which is my real name so I use that on facebook.)

  • I’m not a fan of Sarah Palin.  And while I vote Republican, I’m more of a “California style Republican” meaning that I am fiscally conservative, but do not think the constitution says that gay people cannot serve in the military or get married and I believe that there should be universal health care.  I do have to disagree with you–admittedly, I did not read the facebook comment trail–somewhat in the sense that demagoguery (gosh, did I spell that right?) and the “fiery rhetoric” that has been thrown against Sarah Palin and others is not just a Republican or right-wing thing.  The more that we learn about the Arizona shooter, the more we learn that he is probably more mentall deranged than he is political.  He’s been known to stalk the Congresswoman since 2007, when most people had no idea who Sarah Palin was (or before she started acting more crazy like she is now).  The left leaning media and pundits have said their own fair share of violent rhetoric as well.  The dailykos had a post (since deleted) before the shooting saying that the Arizona Congresswoman was “dead to me” for voting against Pelosi, the DNCC also had a map of Republicans with bullseyes (as opposed to crosshairs, but it’s the same thing).  The Wall Street Journal has an article outlining many other similar mainstream and nutjob liberal comments:

    http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703791904576075660624213434.html

    I do believe that there are wackos (Glenn Beck, for one) who are in the conservative media, but there are also politicians and members of the media (includinig Olbermann) who are on the left, many of whom are hypocritically pointing fingers over the shooting when they’re guilty of doing the exact same thing.

  • I honestly doubt if the rhetoric and anger will change.  There’s too much money at stake.  

  • @ItsWhatEyeKnow - Done!  At first I rejected the request, because I hadn’t read this first!  :)
    @franksabunch - “California Republican”, I love it!  Thanks for your thoughtful analysis Frank.  Not sure if you caught Bill Maher on TV last night.  He can be crass and rude too (like me), but he responds to some of your points about left vs. right, specifically in terms of gun control.  It starts at 2:24.  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qXh156ZafPk Watch it before YouTube removes it.  Couldn’t agree more about Glenn Beck.  In fact, when I first saw that kid’s mugshot, I thought it was a picture of Glenn Beck with a shaved head.  LOL
    @ElusiveWords - You’re right.  The Democrats are pussies, and refuse to stand up to the Assassination Lobby (The NRA).  Very sad.

  • keith olbermann throws out more violence,
    personal insults, threats than probably any other person in the media.
    what a hypocrite. And i’m sorry, but blaming pundits and politicians
    for the terrible actions of one person is as bad as blaming video games
    or the Wachowski brothers or Marilyn Manson. At some point you have to
    just say it’s one crazy person. Stop using this tragedy as political
    ammunition. (pun intended)

  • Yep, just another crazy person, like all the others. http://crooksandliars.com/david-neiwert/terror-arizona-just-another-isolated.

  • Carey, you are sooooo bad but in a good way, Very nice post below the provocative headline.

  • http://shakespearessister.blogspot.com/2011/01/lets-get-this-straight.html may be of use to some people who insist that both sides are just as bad.

  • I
    very much liked what Jon Stewart had to say, especially his thoughts,
    that all of the politicians that went too far (and I don’t care if
    Republicans or Democrats), would step back now and say, this is NOT what
    we intended. The minute of silence
    the USA held on Monday was proof that people care and are horrified by
    those incidents. But how disappointing and shocking to see that after
    this brief moment the political parties were just back on the wagon
    again. From an outsiders perspective it seems that within the last 10 to
    15 years politics in the USA has become rougher to say the least, and
    for sure the Tea-Party rhetoric has definitely not introduced fair and
    objective discussions. I agree with Jon Stewart when he states, that you
    can’t control crazy! But politicians are role models and they should be
    careful with their words. They do have an impact and not only on the
    crazies! It is their job to have an impact on people. But it should be
    for the better of their country and not for their political party. No, I
    don’t think there is a remedy against gunman and massacres. Not the
    best democracy in the world (if this really exists) nor the toughest
    weapon laws can stop an insane murderer from causing immense pain. In
    Germany we have very strict gun laws compared to the US and it still has
    happened twice already. Still, the US is making it too easy for their murders and I believe it is about time to have a meaningful, honest
    discussion about this horrifying and painful topic and not just again
    blaming the other side. That is useless and disrespects the victims and
    their loved ones. I think it is about time to show respect to all the
    people who have died during those massacres by trying to find ways to
    stop this insanity. I believe it would be a good start to think about
    ways how to give help to those “crazies” instead of giving them weapons.
    How to include them, instead of segregating them.

  • @David Ngo - Yeah David, but did you watch the video? He
    apologized. I’m not blaming her, but I do think someone of her stature
    needs to be aware that her actions can have consequences.  Plus, I think you may be forgetting about someone by the name of Glenn Beck! :)
    @Doug H - Great links Doug!  Thanks.
    @Tom - Howard Kurtz says “Don’t Blame Sarah Palin”, but as John Cory points out: “Mr. Kurtz is wrong.

    The killer is not “a lone nutjob.” He is one of us, clothed and fed on perpetual war and the dialog of destruction.

    We have become a nation of, by …and for perpetual war. Perpetual war is our addiction and our language, and as Kurtz so chillingly admits – war is the metaphor of politics and business and daily discourse.

    But I tell you that a nation of perpetual war and constant fear eventually succumbs to self-hatred and self-loathing. It becomes consumed by the value of extremism in the maintenance of empty empire through the deceit of language. A nation of perpetual war numbs itself to violence by constant repetition of the rhetoric of death and mayhem and the slogans of militarism. A nation of perpetual war does not value human life – but rather the hollow rhetoric about human life.

    Mr. Kurtz and others would have us avert our eyes and avoid looking into the mirror and facing the reflection of our words and deeds.

    I can only imagine what Mr. Kurtz and others would have written had the shooter been named Mohammed Abdullah.

    Christina Taylor Greene was 9 years old. She was born on a day of death and madness, September 11, 2001, and she died on a day of death and madness. She is, in the flippant jargon of perpetual war – collateral damage.

    Words have power.

    Yesterday, 20 human beings were shot and 6 human beings were killed.”
    @Sabine S - As usual, Jon Stewart waded through the rhetoric much more brilliantly than anyone and delivered a touching, poignant response: http://www.thedailyshow.com/watch/mon-january-10-2011/arizona-shootings-reactionxcellent summation Bine. I admittedly go for
    shock value with a picture like this, but it ultimately leads people to
    the post. If they read it with an open mind, there’s really not much to
    argue about. Stewart’s soliloquy was so heartfelt, and I know yours
    comes from a place of great emotion. Thank you! xoxo

  • You know, we already have gun control. You have to register it when you buy it, sell it, or whatever. Guns and who owns them are in government records – unless you are illegal and a criminal. You cannot buy a gun outside of your state of residence in most states. There is a background check on you before a legal sale can be made. The problem is the nutjobs and the criminals. They sometimes use guns, but they also use knives, ropes, vehicles, explosives, poison, blunt instruments, and good old fashioned strangulation by hand. If you are talking about a ban on guns, then don’t call it gun control. If you want to live in a place that has no guns in the populace, then go live in some country like China, where only your politicians and military keepers have the guns.

  • @bibiker - Thanks…while those facts may be technically correct; no ordinary citizen in this country needs or should have access to semiautomatic weapons.  That to me is gun control.  Controlling the types of guns available and who can have them.  If you want to shoot your dinner, fine.  You don’t need a Glock with an extended clip to do so.  The nutjob in this case,couldn’t have done near the damage with knives, ropes or the other things you mention.

  • more gun control laws is not a solution either.
    making guns illegal doesn’t take guns out of crazy people’s hands and it
    certainly doesn’t mean less crazy people or less violence. Plus, i can
    just as easily poison or stab someone. should… we outlaw kitchen knives or outlaw cleaning liquids?

    i
    know it’s hard to stomach, but there is no one solution to crazy people
    doing violent things. and blaming one person, blaming a group of
    people, or restricting our freedoms does nothing but make matters worse.

    i’m
    all for people in the public sphere not inciting violence. but nothing
    i’ve read calls for people to act violently. a crazy person could just
    as easily be provoked by a tom & jerry cartoon as an article by
    some writer.

  • Actually I agree with you with the first part and
    I said almost the same in my first comment. Nothing will prevent a
    crazy person from doing harm, and no law as strict as it may be will
    prevent this either but for one, and you know certainly
    more about guns than I do, I assume that it is much harder to kill 6
    people or injure 12 people with a knife rather than a semiautomatic
    weapon. And what is the end of it? What if something like this happens
    again and everybody is having a gun. How do you find out, who is the
    gunman? How many innocent will get shot just in the name of defending
    and protecting. From what I have read, it almost happened this time,
    too.
    But I definitely don’t agree with you with the second part. The
    political rhetoric – on both sides – was going way too far. And there
    is a difference between watching a cartoon and listening to a political
    leader. I am not saying that violent cartoons are a positive thing, but
    if a politicians uses cheap demagogic phrases to discredit other
    politicians than this is just low.
    David, people have died! And
    there is no reason for this, we cannot make sense of it. We try to make
    sense because it helps us to cope. Without this it is just too hard to
    deal with. Everybody deals with it differently and everybody has the
    right to do so. One insane murderer has done this. What has triggered
    his actions, we don’t know and we probably never will. Because we don’t
    think like he does. As most often in life there is not only one reason
    or one aspect why he killed people but whatever the reason, without a
    gun, it would have been damn hard for him to kill them.

  • Thanks Bine. I know that you have been impacted by the gun laws of our country more than anyone I know.
    David,
    someone else raised a similar point. I replied:
    Thanks…while those facts may be technically correct; no ordinary
    citizen in this country needs or should have access to semiautomatic
    weapons. That to me is gun control…Controlling the types of guns
    available and who can have them. If you want to shoot your dinner,
    fine. You don’t need a Glock with an extended clip to do so. The
    nutjob in this case,couldn’t have done near the damage with knives,
    ropes or the other things you mention.
    “Today
    Palin effectively quoted Ronald Reagan arguing that the criminal alone
    is responsible for the crime. “Acts of monstrous criminality stand on
    their own. They begin and end with the criminals who commit them,” she
    said. Good. Then she went on to say that “journalists and pundits should
    not manufacture a blood libel that serves only to incite the very
    hatred and violence they purport to condemn.” Bad. You can’t argue that
    words don’t create criminals and then argue in the next breath that,
    actually, yes, they might.””

  • @CareyGLY - I agree with that. Good points.

  • Sarah Palin… thank god there’s no equivalent in the UK.

  • @Fongster8 - If you want her, we’d be glad to send her over the pond! :)

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *